Germany Hashes Out Compromise to Allow Smaller Stake China Port Deal

October 25, 2022

© Wolfgang Jargstorff / Adobe Stock
© Wolfgang Jargstorff / Adobe Stock

Germany may allow China's Cosco to take a smaller stake than originally planned in a Hamburg port terminal, in what an economy ministry source on Tuesday described as an "emergency solution" to approve the deal but mitigate the impact.

Shipping giant Cosco made a bid last year to take a 35% stake in one of logistics firm HHLA's three terminals in Germany's largest port, but the German coalition has been divided over whether to let the deal go ahead.

The compromise would see Berlin approving a sale of 24.9% of the terminal to Cosco, several government sources said. It will be discussed by the cabinet tomorrow.

The sources said Germany's economy and foreign ministries still wanted to block the deal entirely but were unlikely to succeed, with Chancellor Olaf Scholz expected to prevail over the objections from other ministers.

HHLA declined comment and a Cosco representative was not immediately available for comment

How the government handles the matter is seen as a gauge of how far Germany is willing to toughen its stance on China, its top trading partner, due to concerns about being overly dependent on the increasingly assertive authoritarian country.

The news comes a week before Scholz is due to travel to China.

Supporters of the deal say it will allow Hamburg, where Scholz was mayor before becoming chancellor, to keep pace with rival ports that are also vying for Chinese trade and some of whom are partly owned by Cosco.

"The federal government departments involved see a limit to 24.9 percent as an 'emergency solution' to prevent worse things from happening," the economy ministry source said, adding a smaller stake would give Cosco less say in running the terminal.

"Of course, this does not solve the actual risk issues, so the departments continue to believe that a complete ban is the right way to go," the source said, speaking on condition of anonymity because the matter is confidential.

A second source said the government could try to attach additional guarantees to the deal to further mitigate Cosco's influence on the running of the port terminal.

"Of course it's now up to Cosco to say we're also happy with 24.9 percent," a third source said.

Beijing has previously said it hoped Germany would view the deal in an "objective and rational light" without politicising economic relations.

Andreas Audretsch, a senior lawmaker from Scholz's coalition partner the Greens, said his party wanted to ban the deal.

"The fact that Cosco should now take over less than 25 percent of the terminal is not a compromise, but an emergency solution to prevent worse things from happening," he said.

"Germany can no longer afford to be naïve when dealing with autocracies."


(Reuters - Reporting by Christian Kraemer, Andreas Rinke, Alexander Ratz and Jan Schwartz Additional reporting by Brenda Goh Writing by Maria Sheahan and Matthias Williams Editing by Miranda Murray, Mark Potter and Emelia Sithole-Matarise)

Logistics News

DP World, Asian Terminals Inc. Invest $100M to Boost Capacity at Manila South Harbor

DP World, Asian Terminals Inc. Invest $100M to Boost Capacity at Manila South Harbor

PD Ports Outlines Plans to Develop UK Offshore Wind Hub

PD Ports Outlines Plans to Develop UK Offshore Wind Hub

DP World Begins $165 Million Expansion of Maputo Container Terminal Capacity

DP World Begins $165 Million Expansion of Maputo Container Terminal Capacity

Port Canaveral Invests $500 Million in Five-Year Port-Wide Improvement Plan

Port Canaveral Invests $500 Million in Five-Year Port-Wide Improvement Plan

Subscribe for Maritime Logistics Professional E‑News

Turkey maintains its commitment to the contested "Kanal Istanbul" project
Media reports that Malaysian Petronas is accused of violating Sarawak State laws
Asian spot LNG prices drop to new lows of 1 year on weak demand