Q-ships

Jul 27, 2010, 7:00AM EST
Q-ships
A wolf in sheep’s clothing, but largely ineffectual

 Q-ships were merchant vessels drafted into wartime service, armed with concealed heavy weapons and sent out to lure enemy submarines into combat.  They were used extensively by the Royal Navy during both World Wars and, to a lesser extent, by the US Navy during World War II.  The term is derived from the homeport utilized by most of the Royal Navy vessels on these missions: Queenstown, Ireland.  The Royal Navy commissioned 200 Q-ships during World War I.  A typical Q-ship resembled a tramp steamer, and probably was one prior to conversion.  It was equipped with deck guns hidden behind panels that could be dropped quickly for combat.  The Q-ship generally carried a cargo of balsa or cork so as to remain buoyant even if struck by a torpedo.  During World War I, German submarines (U-boats) carried a limited number of torpedoes and preferred to attack on the surface using deck guns when feasible.  The Q-ships were designed as bait to lure the U-boat into a surface attack.  The guns on a Q-ship were generally superior to those on a U-boat, plus they had the element of surprise.  In 150 engagements, Royal Navy Q-ships sank 14 German Navy U-boats and damaged 60, while losing 27 of their own.  With the coming of World War II, submarine technology had changed.  Few submarines engaged in surface attacks.  The Royal Navy commissioned nine Q-ships when war broke out.  Two were promptly sunk by U-boats and the remaining Q-boats were converted to other work.  Shortly after the US entered World War II, five merchant vessels were converted by the US Navy to operate as Q-ships off the Atlantic coast.  One was promptly sunk by a German U-boat and the others proved unsuccessful.  There have been some suggestions that Q-ships should be utilized in the Indian Ocean to lure Somali pirates into making attacks.  Because the pirates have mistakenly attacked armed warships, there seems to be little need for subterfuge here.
 
Report abuse



Bookmark this page to:Add to Faves Add to MyAOL Add to Simpy Add to Delicious Add to Live Add to Digg Add to Newsvine Add to Reddit Add to Multiply Add to Blogmarks Add to Yahoo MyWeb Add to Slashdot Add to Mister Wong Add to Spurl Add to Furl Add to Link-a-Gogo Add to Yahoo Bookmarks Add to Twitter Add to Facebook Add to Diigo Add to Mixx Add to Segnalo Add to StumbleUpon Add to Magnolia Add to Ask Add to Backflip Add to Terchnorati Add to Google Bookmarks Add to MySpace

Comments
Steve Toby
Mr. Bryant's account, although correct, isn't quite complete. While the term and the tactics of Q-ships is of Allied origin, German raiders in both wars functioned that way with a slightly different emphasis.

The most spectacular incident involving a German Q-ship was when the disguised raider Kormoran was approached for questioning by an Australian cruiser in Western Australian waters. The resulting encounter, described by German survivors, was not believed until recent discovery of the wreck of the cruiser gave additional information. Apparently the cruiser came alongside the raider at 1500 meters to inspect it closely, and the Germans unmasked their 15-cm (5.9 inch) guns and opened fire, also launching a torpedo. The cruiser replied with her 6-inch main battery but at such point-blank range there was little advantage in being a warship -- even without fire direction equipment the German guns scored multiple hits. The German raider's mine magazine blew up, taking her engine room with it, and the Germans abandoned ship, while the badly disabled cruiser limped away at 6 knots into deteriorating weather. She was never seen again until the wreck was rediscovered and there were no survivors.
8/1/2010 11:40:28 AM
 

Sign in

Latest blog comments

2/4/2012

dilipan thomas
well there is no job for most people who has finished studi...

2/2/2012

Saunders Jones
Joe, You are right on regarding both GMATS and the Super...

1/25/2012

Joseph Keefe
Mark: You get the prize, indeed. Thanks for weighing in....

1/24/2012

Mark Sales
An apt and appropriate view of the situation. It also shou...

1/24/2012

Eric Goldring
I just wrote an article on my blog about the hype which has...

1/20/2012

Shiran Senanayake
I believe that Cruise Masters are fatigued with so many por...

1/19/2012

Alan Loynd
Absolutely correct. With the largest passenger ships now...

1/19/2012

James Lynch
Well stated. The need for regulation is obvious in any fie...

1/19/2012

Eugene (Gene) Horton
Dear Greg, I read your article on “size matters” and found...

1/19/2012

Laurie Thomas
Joe, to add to John's comment, here's another gem/bad news ...